BesslerWheel.com

[AB Hammer]

In my opinion Scott F. Hall is a very skilled fraudster.
He shows his wheels on youtube and it tends to make everybody think he has done it. He also has his comment restricted to friends only so he can't get a negative response posted. He doesn't claim a working wheel outright, but with suttle hints. I figured that I should post this since I found it.

So here it is Scott F Hall's again but with a Bhaskara Wheel.

first available video
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=PN4x0N-X2fU
2nd available video
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=lLBcy3g7tDI
finished available video
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-gFsqXsAkQ8

And maybe he just likes the attention.

_________________
"Our education can be the limitation to our imagination, and our dreams"
________________

With out a dream, there is no vision.

Alan

[AB Hammer]

I was wrong, he does claim a working wheel and if you reed anything before from the youtube search it is oveous even before he built it.

[winkle]

[KAS]

It is slowing if you observe closely.

also, the answers there when someone asks:-

"I would love to make one of these for my house.Any tips?"

hallsf Reply

"Yeah, you can find two good bearings for a big, heavy wheel like this for only $10 at Home Depot. They're stainless steel with cylindrical outer sleeves--made in Russia--with a 1 inch diameter center hole (which nicely fits a 1 inch diameter oak dowel you can also buy there). The oak dowel can simply be glued into a 1 inch diameter hole you drill through the center of your wheel".

IMO, without proof its just a nicely balanced wheel with good quality bearings.

I have personally spun a heavy wheel for alot longer than the film on standard pillow bearings.

KAS

_________________
“We have no right to assume that any physical laws exist, or if they have existed up until now, that they will continue to exist in a similar manner in the future.”

Quote By Max Planck father of Quantum physics 1858 - 1947

[jim_mich]

These demonstrations never show the wheels doing any real work. All they need do is add fins on the OD (or connect it to another wheel with fins on the OD) and then immerse the fins in water. If the wheel can maintain speed while stirring the water then the water will heat up and prove the wheel works and outputs extra energy. Then post a 20 minute video showing the wheel working while a thermometer rises. Also the working guts of the wheel must be out in the open and specifications for independent duplication must be provided. Anything less will not be believed.

[james kelly]

Thank you Jim Mich for a very poor view point

[jim_mich]

James Kelly, why do you think its a very poor view point? The burden of proof is on anyone claiming to have a PMM. Anyone claiming success needs to prove the success, else none will believe the claim. Of course if one wants to keep the idea secret then proof is not relevant. If one wants to retain intellectual property rights then proper legal measures must be pursued before public disclosure of the guts of the wheel.

[AB Hammer]

jim_mich

Thanks for clearing this up. To show a true runner it would be wise to take the proper precautions, and then show what it can do not and not just spin.





Alan

[axel]

[Alastair Carnegie]

I hope you will be relieved of your apastasy, after you have either made a "Rock-N-Roll" Bessler Wheel for yourself, or examined one made for you. The fact that it works, and is fully consistent with classical mechanics, is as Professor Walter Lewin of MIT says, "non negotiable" Facts are facts after all, and fraud is fraud for all to see!

[primemignonite]

As regards any who might claim working OU wheels and the point about this nicely made by Jim_Misch, the following maxim of law applies:

"Upon him who advocates lays the burden of proof, not upon he who denies."

To me, this means that claimants of working wheels are obligated absolutely TO PROVE their claim, and, that it is not the obligation of any deniers of that claim to.

James

_________________
Cynic-In-Chief, BesslerWheel (Ret.); Perpetualist First-Class