My Original Idea

[JAL]

Walt, I might be able to sue Scott for how I have been treated at his establishment. The law allows for it. He has knowingly allowed people to be abusive towards me. I could probably get the house he lives in. That's what makes America great, the ability to have grievances compensated for.
This is a public space. Just like going to McDonald's. And at McDonald's I could sue them for failing to maintain a safe environment.
The law allows for that. And what would you and Alan do? It doesn't matter to you guys because you'd blame it all on Scott for not moderating you guys. It's his forum, right?
That's what the law says.
It's funny as hell when the people with the biggest mouths have nothing to show. And that's going back over 12 years non builders are openly hateful. Even ME forgot math because no AB Hammer loved it 💖❤️💖❤️🎶🎵💖❤️🎶🎵💖❤️

[Georg Künstler]

Hi JAL,

sometimes you overlook something.

http://alt.kuenstler-energie.de/

and
http://kuenstler-energie.de/

not only you are a model builder.
But you are right, the most of the People only like to talk.

[JAL]

I'll simplify. My build works, then according to Scott Ellis I am the Devil. This is because no angel {American} was willing to work.
And no one in here can show an American build.
Just stating a fact. No American builds.
Since I am 1/2 Norwegian I don't count as a build.

[WaltzCee]

Walt, I might be able to sue Scott for how I have been treated at his establishment. The law allows for it. He has knowingly allowed people to be abusive towards me. I could probably get the house he lives in. That's what makes America great, the ability to have grievances compensated for.
This is a public space. Just like going to McDonald's. And at McDonald's I could sue them for failing to maintain a safe environment.
The law allows for that. And what would you and Alan do? It doesn't matter to you guys because you'd blame it all on Scott for not moderating you guys. It's his forum, right?
That's what the law says.
It's funny as hell when the people with the biggest mouths have nothing to show. And that's going back over 12 years non builders are openly hateful. Even ME forgot math because no AB Hammer loved it 💖❤️💖❤️🎶🎵💖❤️🎶🎵💖❤️

I think maybe Scott should file charges against you. Mr. Stalker man.

[JAL]

Hi JAL,

sometimes you overlook something.

http://alt.kuenstler-energie.de/

and
http://kuenstler-energie.de/

not only you are a model builder.
But you are right, the most of the People only like to talk.

Okay, now you're just showing off 😉😀😉
My wood working isn't nearly as good. Between you and Visitor, kind of helping to keep me motivated.

[WaltzCee]

Debbie,
When some of what he does is lie, I should be upset. And if he was ignoring me, he shouldn't have been talking about.
When I posted an idea of how Bessler might have made one of his wheels, he said it would not work. No discussion and no reason for his comment.
He did say someone already tried that design and gave me a link to about 100. I didn't see one similar.
So at no time did he show or give a basis for his claims about my idea.
So if what you say is true, that we should be discussing how Bessler might have done it, you might mention that to Ralph.
As for your idea, if all 3 boxes are the same, your weights will always be in a balanced position and not able to develop torque or momentum.

finis

@Jim-L

IMO this forum should be for solving the puzzle of Bessler's wheel. Ralph has put you on ignore, but you register as a different user just to piss him off. (ooops did I swear?)

I don't usually take sides, but on this one I must.

Ralph has shown fairness and tolerance towards you. But it seems to me that you are now stalking him.

Please can this stop? It is destroying my enjoyment of this site, and I'm sure it is getting in the way of serious study of the BW puzzle. Or is it that you are hell bent on stopping any interesting thread with your mind games.

Just because you can do your sums doesn't mean you are any better than anyone else here.

My humble advice would be to go away and play on your own.

Phew, I feel better now I've got that off my chest.

Debbie

PS Why don't you get that chip off your shoulder and try to get on with people ... please have some respect.



-----------------------------------

How long have you been lying to us about having a working wheel. And we shouldn't be upset?

[WaltzCee]

That is my point Ralph. Someone posts a design and you were changing the discussion to a different design.
Why is it that if I post a design, the better subject is a design you remember that did not work ?
I do believe you are jealous of me. My work is supported by mathematics. And yes, in engineering that is important. Kind of strange that an engineer would go away from that.
I do plan on demonstarting my principle. It allows for auto-dynamic behavior. And that is what perpetual motion is. I would say that what I have found is a new principle in Engineering. And oncce demonstrated, everyone one in here will be talking about it because it will show where the engineer leaves the math behind, it is not for a good reason.
And no, I am not in a hole. I am on a mountain. It is not always easy to tell somewhat what the view looks like.
But as has been said, Rome wasn't built in a day.
Of course, my brother Harold always said that if you can't dazzle them with brilliance, then baffle them with b.s.

do you plan on doing this sometime before Hell Freezes Over?

[agor95]

I registered on this site way back in 2008.

There was a flame war in progress and 'P-Motion' was the target.

There was ill will in both directions from what I remember.

Would you like to include the date of your quotes so people can see how old they are and not relevant for this decade.

Can you let us know what you are doing on the Bessler Wheel quest these past 2 years?

It is said that the Devil gives work to idle hands.

I think we have the right to know as you are wasting all our time reading your posts.

[silent]

.

[WaltzCee]

anyone can post a discordant note - time to strum a proper tune.

• • First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—
    
    Because I was not a socialist.
    
    Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out—
    Because I was not a trade unionist.
    
    Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—
    Because I was not a Jew.
    
    Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.
    • • Friedrich Gustav Emil Martin Niemöller

Are you talking to me, agor?

[WaltzCee]

I'm American and have done 2 builds (both failed), but I learned a lot with them. I don't share my results on here though although I do share with a couple of trusted members offline.

silent

Everyone certainly does it the way they want to, that's the nature of Freedom. It's beautiful being an American. I've shared sim results with everybody on this forum. Although I haven't shared results of prototype experiments. The idea that just because you don't post what you're building means you're not building is total blarney. I have noticed that some commandeer ideas and don't credit the source. That's a bit of a turn off and not conducive to cause people to want to share.

I've also noticed that some people have horrible reading comprehension skills, at least I think when they're trying to have horrible reading comprehension skills.

[JAL]

It's odd that this forum is meant to be about realizing Bessler's work. Yet the most credible people have no work to show. I think those people will always say what they have is better even after Bessler's wheel is realized. It's all they have.

[ovyyus]

This forum is 'meant' for discussion.

[JAL]

Then I am in the wrong place oyvvus. I hope you will accept my apology.

[ovyyus]

You'll say the opposite in 10 minutes. You aren't sorry, you crave attention and will say anything to get it.