Posted by Jonathan (68.14.212.239) on November 01, 2003 at 16:41:28:
In Reply to: Re: Correct me if I'm wrong Georg posted by Jonathan on November 01, 2003 at 16:17:50:
It occurs to me that my posts may sound mean, I don't want there to be any hard feelings. But if you veiw this from my prospective: many of your posts express your opinion on peoples ideas and you say things about resonance and trouble forces that no one understands. This thread is somewhat related to my fustration with working on perpetual motion and to the 'Comment for Scott' thread. I'm not going to live forever and I can't predict the future, so for all I know I may not be able to work on this every day in years to come. I just want to get a working device as soon as possible.
: I'll see if I get a chance. But in the mean time, why didn't that one you built work? I have to admit I had to make some changes in order to make the device easier to build, and you will likely say that those changes are what caused it to not work, though if I understand it's working then the changes I made shouldn't matter. Regardless, you made one and so by definition it was exactly to your specifications, and yet it didn't run.
: : : Or could it be that he is nuts? Regardless, I have no faith in your explaination because he would really have to be nuts to think that is the best way to go about introducing the device. If he want the heats off him he could just make a complete description of the making and working of the device and go around posting it all over the internet. It would be out and around so fast that whatever imagined conspiracy that is against him would have no chance, not to mention that when everybody knows about this device there is no point to harming the inventor of the device. I've been to his site, it makes little sense to me, and the language barrier doesn't help. I made a model, it didn't work. He made a model, it didn' work. How about he tries a new idea?
: : : As for me, I've pretty much given up hope on a mechanical perpetual motion, but am quite interested in the electromagnetic kind, esp. when it comes to SED theory, or TB's scalar electromagnetics.
: : : : I believe that Georg believes that he has a design for a O/U engine based on something other than gravity (what's missing off his web page ?). He is worried about his personal safety & his reputation should he try to release it before its time (the world needs softening up somewhat although Salem witch hunts went out of favour a long time ago). It is much more powerful than JB's gravity driven mechanism which he considers a toy (in the nicest way) but before releasing the device Georg wants the world to become familiar with & accepting of his Mechanical Harmonic Generator (gravity driven). If he can give us timely 'pointers & clues' we will understand & build the "plucker" so that the heat comes off him personally & we will then become accepting of his more powerfull device. In other words the Bessler Wheel is the "undercard" to the main event. I could mention the obvious that a video is worth 10,000 words? Does this explain why Georg is so insistant that he has the answer to Besslers Wheel ?
: : : :
: : : : : : I do not understand any of Mr. Georg Kunstler's posts. I've been waiting to see if maybe I'm just misinterpreting what he says, but he manages, in every post, to imply that he knows how to make a perpetual wheel and kinda gives hints to the people here to 'lead them to the truth'. I've gone to his website and made a model of the COG he's always talking about and it didn't work. I of course admit that I may have misunderstood how it's supposed to work, as I think I've seen two versions by him, but regardless, if it works he should build one and show us.
: : : : : : I saw a picture somewhere on this site of a beautiful machine and it was not working. IIRC, it was built by him and so it would seem to me that if even he couldn't get it to work, then the idea doesn't.
: : : : : Hi Jonathan,
: : : : : the beautiful machine still exists, this is the basic, which is
: : : : : necessary to pass the gate. Wheels in wheels while not turning !!
: : : : : This technic was shown in the 'Drehmomentspeicher'. You can't g